| Date | Location | Result | |
| 5/4/2019 | Tiffin, Ohio | Findlay 9, Tiffin 8 | Box score |
| 5/2/2019 | Tiffin, Ohio | Tiffin 11, Lake Erie 8 | Box score |
| 5/2/2019 | Tiffin, Ohio | Findlay 18, Walsh 7 | Box score |
| 4/28/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 18, Lake Erie 7 | Box score |
| 4/28/2019 | Pepper Pike, OH | Findlay 18, Ursuline 3 | Box score |
| 4/27/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 14, Ohio Valley 12 | Box score |
| 4/26/2019 | Philippi, WV | Walsh 20, Alderson Broaddus 7 | Box score |
| 4/26/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 17, Ursuline 3 | Box score |
| 4/26/2019 | Findlay, OH | Findlay 17, Lake Erie 7 | Box score |
| 4/24/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 17, Davis & Elkins 3 | Box score |
| 4/24/2019 | Vienna, WV | Ohio Valley 13, Alderson Broaddus 12 | Box score |
| 4/20/2019 | Findlay, OH | Tiffin 13, Findlay 12 | Box score |
| 4/20/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 14, Alderson Broaddus 10 | Box score |
| 4/20/2019 | Painesville, OH | Lake Erie 22, Ursuline 3 | Box score |
| 4/18/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 18, Ohio Valley 8 | Box score |
| 4/16/2019 | Edinboro, PA | Edinboro 14, Lake Erie 10 | Box score |
| 4/14/2019 | Painesville, OH | Lake Erie 20, Ohio Valley 13 | Box score |
| 4/14/2019 | Pepper Pike, OH | Walsh 16, Ursuline 5 | Box score |
| 4/14/2019 | Findlay, OH | Florida Southern 19, Findlay 5 | Box score |
| 4/14/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 20, Davis & Elkins 9 | Box score |
| 4/12/2019 | Painesville, OH | Walsh 16, Lake Erie 11 | Box score |
| 4/12/2019 | Findlay, OH | Findlay 20, Davis & Elkins 7 | Box score |
| 4/12/2019 | Pepper Pike, OH | Ohio Valley 15, Ursuline 9 | Box score |
| 4/12/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Florida Southern 17, Tiffin 4 | Box score |
| 4/10/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 14, District of Columbia 6 | Box score |
| 4/7/2019 | Philippi, WV | Lake Erie 17, Alderson Broaddus 4 | Box score |
| 4/7/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 14, Ursuline 13 | Box score |
| 4/6/2019 | North Canton, OH | Tiffin 11, Walsh 8 | Box score |
| 4/6/2019 | Vienna, WV | Findlay 22, Ohio Valley 12 | Box score |
| 4/5/2019 | Elkins, WV | Lake Erie 19, Davis & Elkins 8 | Box score |
| 4/4/2019 | North Canton, OH | Findlay 16, Walsh 6 | Box score |
| 4/4/2019 | Vienna, WV | Tiffin 15, Ohio Valley 4 | Box score |
| 4/2/2019 | Waynesburg, PA | Davis & Elkins 23, Waynesburg 2 | Box score |
| 4/2/2019 | New Wilmington, PA | Westminster (PA) 15, Ursuline 11 | Box score |
| 3/31/2019 | Findlay, OH | Findlay 19, Alderson Broaddus 3 | Box score |
| 3/30/2019 | Georgetown, KY | Walsh 21, Georgetown (KY) 13 | Box score |
| 3/30/2019 | Wooster, OH | College of Wooster 15, Ursuline 5 | Box score |
| 3/29/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 15, Alderson Broaddus 1 | Box score |
| 3/27/2019 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 14, Walsh 8 | Box score |
| 3/27/2019 | Elkins, WV | Wheeling Jesuit 15, Davis & Elkins 14 | Box score |
| 3/26/2019 | Philippi, WV | Ursuline 15, Alderson Broaddus 12 | Box score |
| 3/26/2019 | Painesville, OH | Lindenwood (MO) 10, Lake Erie 2 | Box score |
| 3/24/2019 | New Wilmington, PA | Ohio Valley 20, Westminster 8 | Box score |
| 3/24/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Lindenwood (MO) 10, Tiffin 9 | Box score |
| 3/22/2019 | Findlay, OH | Colorado Mesa 16, Ursuline 0 | Box score |
| 3/22/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 12, Charleston (WV) 7 | Box score |
| 3/20/2019 | Findlay, OH | Colorado Mesa 12, Findlay 11 | Box score |
| 3/20/2019 | Washington, DC | Ohio Valley 19, Dist. of Columbia 3 | Box score |
| 3/20/2019 | South Euclid, OH | Ursuline 17, Notre Dame (OH) 12 | Box score |
| 3/19/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 15, Lawrence Tech 12 | Box score |
| 3/19/2019 | Erie, PA | Lake Erie 14, Gannon 8 | Box score |
| 3/19/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 17, Bethany 2 | Box score |
| 3/18/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Colorado Mesa 14, Tiffin 12 | Box score |
| 3/17/2019 | Buckhannon, WV | West Va. Wesleyan 12, Ohio Valley 9 | Box score |
| 3/17/2019 | Wheeling, WV | Wheeling Jesuit 11, Lake Erie 9 | Box score |
| 3/17/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 15, Notre Dame (OH) 9 | Box score |
| 3/16/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Regis 18, Tiffin 6 | Box score |
| 3/15/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 21, West Va. Wesleyan 4 | Box score |
| 3/14/2019 | Findlay, OH | Regis 17, Findlay 13 | Box score |
| 3/14/2019 | Wilson, NC | Barton 14, Ohio Valley 13 | Box score |
| 3/14/2019 | North Canton, OH | Walsh 21, Notre Dame (OH) 6 | Box score |
| 3/14/2019 | Elkins, WV | Davis & Elkins 17, Mars Hill 9 | Box score |
| 3/12/2019 | Seneca, SC | Ohio Valley 15, Southern Wesleyan 10 | Box score |
| 3/12/2019 | Philippi, WV | Alderson Broaddus 18, Mars Hill 11 | Box score |
| 3/3/2019 | Boone, NC | Davis & Elkins 16, Lees-McRae 9 | Box score |
| 3/11/2019 | Huntsville, AL | Alabama-Huntsville 14, Ursuline 1 | Box score |
| 3/10/2019 | Findlay, OH | McKendree 12, Findlay 11 | Box score |
| 3/10/2019 | Rome, GA | Shorter 15, Ursuline 14 | Box score |
| 3/10/2019 | Philippi, WV | Wheeling Jesuit 22, Alderson Broaddus 10 | Box score |
| 3/9/2019 | Indianapolis, IN | Indianapolis 26, Lake Erie 2 | Box score |
| 3/8/2019 | Shepherdstown, WV | Shepherd 21, Alderson Broaddus 11 | Box score |
| 3/8/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 13, McKendree 8 | Box score |
| 3/7/2019 | Montreat, NC | Davis & Elkins 21, Montreat (NC) 3 | Box score |
| 3/7/2019 | Painesville, OH | Lake Erie 18, Northern Michigan 17 | Box score |
| 3/7/2019 | Steubenville, OH | Ohio Valley 16, Franciscan 5 | Box score |
| 3/6/2019 | Montevallo, AL | Findlay 24, Montevallo 6 | Box score |
| 3/6/2019 | Lock Haven, PA | Lock Haven 16, Alderson Broaddus 7 | Box score |
| 3/5/2019 | Brevard, NC | Davis & Elkins 16, Brevard 8 | Box score |
| 3/5/2019 | Wise, VA | Tiffin 16, Virginia-Wise 5 | Box score |
| 3/5/2019 | Wise, VA | Lincoln Memorial 14, Walsh 11 | Box score |
| 3/4/2019 | Huntsville, AL | Alabama-Huntsville 8, Findlay 6 | Box score |
| 3/3/2019 | Erie, PA | Mercyhurst 16, Tiffin 6 | Box score |
| 3/2/2019 | Painesville, OH | Lake Erie 12, Charleston (WV) 11 | Box score |
| 3/2/2019 | Ada, OH | Ursuline 12, Ohio Northern 11 | Box score |
| 3/2/2019 | Greeneville, TN | Walsh 16, Tusculum 7 | Box score |
| 3/1/2019 | Findlay, OH | Lindenwood (MO) 6, Findlay 3 | Box score |
| 3/1/2019 | Slippery Rock, PA | Slippery Rock 7, Tiffin 4 | Box score |
| 2/27/2019 | Edinboro, PA | Walsh 11, Edinboro 8 | Box score |
| 2/27/2019 | Charleston, WV | Charleston 15, Alderson Broaddus 5 | Box score |
| 2/25/2019 | Elkins, WV | Lincoln Memorial 15, Davis & Elkins 4 | Box score |
| 2/24/2019 | Wheeling, WV | Findlay 21, Wheeling Jesuit 8 | Box score |
| 2/24/2019 | Erie, PA | Mercyhurst 15, Ursuline 3 | Box score |
| 2/23/2019 | Indiana, PA | Indiana (PA) 17, Findlay 5 | Box score |
| 2/23/2019 | Philippi, WV | Roberts Wesleyan 23, Alderson Broaddus 4 | Box score |
| 2/23/2019 | Lock Haven, PA | Tiffin 8, Lock Haven 5 | Box score |
| 2/22/2019 | Painesville, OH | Grand Valley State 14, Lake Erie 4 | Box score |
| 2/21/2019 | Sylvania, OH | Walsh 22, Lourdes 3 | Box score |
| 2/20/2019 | Philippi, WV | West Va. Wesleyan 9, Alderson Broaddus 8 | Box score |
| 2/17/2019 | Philippi, WV | Davenport 21, Alderson Broaddus 7 | Box score |
| 2/16/2019 | Indianapolis, IN | Indianapolis 17, Findlay 5 | Box score |
| 2/15/2019 | Tiffin, OH | Tiffin 11, Davenport 6 | Box score |